The gender pay gap in South Australia is around half the national figure – but is this really good news?

This is the sixth post in the series on inequality in South Australia, with the early posts dealing with inequality between households and the later posts looking at structural inequalities. This post continues the focus on structural inequality, and looks at gender inequality – or at least one aspect of gendered economic inequality.

Gender Pay Gaps – Official

The “official” gender pay gap figures used by the government’s Workplace Gender Equity Agency show that the gender pay gap is significantly narrower in South Australia than in the country as a whole. At 7.4% the gender pay gap in South Australia is around half the national average, and is the lowest in the country. However, there is devil in the detail of this official figure.

While the gender pay gap is lower in South Australia, this gap is on lower wages overall and does not necessarily reflect women doing relatively better. ABS Labour Force data shows that the $1541 per week full-time ordinary time earnings for women in South Australia was 95.8% of the equivalent figure at the national level. For men in SA, full-time ordinary time earnings were 89% of the national figure. In theory, this difference could mean that SA has proportionately more women in higher paying jobs, but more likely it reflects labour market segmentation where proportionately more women are in jobs with wages set nationally (e.g. minimum wages or modern awards), while men are overly represented in non-award industries where wages may differ more across the country.

This suggests that much of the difference in the national and SA gender pay gaps is not about women’s pay, but rather because men’s wages in SA are disproportionately lower than the national average. Put another way, rather than the labour market in SA bringing women’s wages up closer to men’s, it is an “equalling down” based on relatively lower men’s wages.

This creates particular challenges for the left and the union movement: how to increase wages in South Australia to closer to national averages without also increasing the gender wage gap? Obviously, a focus on gender segmentation and increasing wages in highly feminized industries like childcare is a start, but it should also be a factor in changes to enterprise bargaining currently under consideration.

Bigger Gender Pay Gaps Beyond the Headline Figure

The “official gender pay gap” based on full time ordinary time figures is only one measure of gendered pay inequality. The table below shows a range of key gender pay gap and wage share data for Australia and South Australia and is necessary because the full-time ordinary time data is limited. It ignores (and arguably institutionalises) gender differences in access to overtime and bonuses.

The first line in the table is the official full-time ordinary time data, but as can be seen in the second line of the table, when overtime, bonuses and other extras are taken into account in total full-time weekly earnings the gender pay gap is much larger. It is still less of a gap in South Australia, but the difference in the national and SA figures is narrower.

However, even these full-time figures ignore the over-representation of women in part-time and casual work. As evident in the third line in the table, the gender pay gap jumps markedly when the average weekly earnings of all employees are included. The gap between South Australian and national figures is much lower here, presumably because of a higher proportion of women in part-time jobs in South Australia. This is confirmed by the gender wage share data in the bottom line of the table, where the difference between the national and SA figures is lowest.

Gender Pay Gaps, May 2022

	Australia	SA
F/T Ordinary Time Earnings	14.1%	7.4%
F/T Total Earnings	16.5%	9.6%
Average Earnings	29.7%	27.7%
Women’s Participation Rate	62.2%	58.4%
Gender Wage Share	39.0%	40.0%

Gender Wage Share

I have set out elsewhere a rationale for considering, alongside the traditional average pay gap data, the gender wage share – that is, the female share of the total wage pool. The importance of that wage share data can be seen here.

Both nationally and in South Australia, the female half of the population takes home around 40% of the total wage pool. In actual dollars, the May 2022 figures show that men as a whole in South Australia take home $221m more than women each week, for an annual return to gender of $11.5bn. To put that in the context of the local economy, the total sales revenue of South Australia’s biggest company, SANTOS was around $6.9bn in 2021, around 60% of the gender wage share differential.

As I argued in an earlier post about the corresponding national figure of a $200bn annual wage differential, the aggregate gender wage share difference is a significant economic flow that not just reflects but contributes to the reproduction of that inequality.

Changes Over Time

The 2022 data above shows, in short, that while the official gender pay gap is much lower in South Australia, the benefit of this is diluted by lesser participation in paid work by women (both relatively lower participation in the workforce, and relatively fewer hours by those engaged in paid work). As we will see below, these patterns are not new.

The following graph shows the full-time (all earnings) gender wage gap in Australia and South Australia over the last 25 years. While the data on South Australia is more volatile, the gender pay gap in South Australia has generally been below the national figure. In both data sets, the gender pay gap shrinks in the late 1990s, but grows again from 2000 nationally and from 2004 in South Australia through to 2014. The gap then shrinks over the next few years before flattening out in the last few years.

However, the gender wage share data tells a slightly different story. There is little difference in the time-series data on South Australian and Australian women’s share of their respective total wage pools. In both data sets there is a small but sustained increase in women’s share (apart from a small dip after the Global Financial Crisis in 2008) (see the black SA line in the graph below). In South Australia women’s share of the total wage pool increased from 35.1% in November 1994 to 40% in May this year. The national figures showed an increase from 33.1% to 39% over the same period.

Crucially though, this story is set against the backdrop noted in a number of my previous posts of a general decline in South Australia’s economy relative to the national economy. This was evident in SA’s share of household income and the labour share of the economy. The graph below shows that this decline also impacts on the gender wage share. While the top line shows that women have been increasing their share of the South Australian wages pool, with that pool in relative decline, South Australian women’s share of the national wages pool has actually shrunk from 2.6% in 1994 to 2.41% this year.

While this decline in South Australian women’s share of the national wage pool is alarming, it is made even more problematic because, as noted in the previous post, the wage pool itself is declining as a proportion of the economy.

Summing Up

The official gender pay gap data shows South Australia doing relatively well with the smallest gap in the country, but a closer look at the data tells a less rosy story. The smaller gender wage gap is based on lower women’s participation rates and relatively lower male wages in South Australia. It is not a story of greater female agency in the labour market. The national/SA differences almost disappear when the share of the total wage pool is considered.

And regardless of the comparative story, the gender wage inequalities in South Australia remain significant – with a 27.7% gap in average earnings leading to an aggregate $11.5bn annual wage gap. Further, while women’s share of the South Australian wage pool has increased over the last 25 years, these gains are undermined by the shrinking of that wage pool relative to the national wage pool – a national pool which, with historically low labour shares of GDP, is itself shrinking relative to the economy as a whole.

Beneath the headline gender pay gap data, for South Australian women workers there is a particularly problematic intersection of gender, geographic and class inequalities.